Often when schedules are supplied, he could be offered that have 24 hours of your day you to do perhaps not match with this time because inside the actual records. One such example happens in Harry Potter and Prisoner out-of Azkaban whenever Sybill Trelawney means 16 Oct as the Tuesday, even when https://brightwomen.net/tr/sili-kadinlari/ 16 October 1993 try a tuesday.

There are even contradictions during the guides of this type. Such, in the Harry Potter as well as the Goblet away from Flame, one another step one Sep and you may dos September are given because Mondays and you may, in Harry Potter and Prisoner away from Azkaban, Buckbeak’s demonstration is decided to the 20 April, but cautious parsing of text message shows that it could enjoys took place no afterwards than just February.

And additionally, in Harry Potter and the Goblet away from Fire they claim the Champions was chose into Saturday 29 Oct, but 31 October are a monday for the 1994.

Into the a bankruptcy proceeding off Quidditch From the Many years, they claim your basic Quidditch Business Glass was held within the 1473. If your tournament are stored all of the few years, it problems to the statement during the Goblet away from Flames that 1994 Community Cup was new 422nd. If the Quidditch From the Ages is good, the newest 422nd Quidditch Globe Cup do indeed belong the entire year 3161, but if Goblet out-of Flame is great, the first Globe Cup had been kept during the 306.

Historical difficulties [ ]

Whilst the show, with respect to the schedule produced from the Chamber away from Gifts source, is determined on the 1990s, the fresh new collection have a tendency to looks as though it is invest the fresh new late 1990s so you can mid-2000s, roughly concurrent into the guide of one’s guides. Inside the Harry Potter while the 50 % of-Blood Prince, Cornelius Fudge spends a male pronoun to refer to the “predecessor” of your Primary Minister of Uk. According to more than timeline, this would take place in the summer months out of 1996, if Finest Minister is actually John Major, whoever immediate ancestor are a lady (is why first meeting with Fudge, the book mentions new election, but Significant wasn’t very first selected and only took over immediately after Thatcher retired.

It’s possible, but not impractical, that Fudge might be referring to a more faraway predecessor, as Thatcher took work environment before Fudge allegedly turned Minister to have Wonders. (Regardless if one can envision a scenario in which Fudge is actually delegated by the Minister to possess Miracle in order to satisfy to the Primary Minister while he, Fudge, was a student in a smaller sized workplace.) Additionally, the brand new identification and you may reputation of the top Minister represented seems to a whole lot more closely match that Tony Blair than of John Significant. A blog post in the Daily Post notes you to definitely Rowling is romantic toward then-Chancellor of the Exchequer Gordon Brownish (will seen as an opponent so you’re able to Blair’s leaders of your Work Party, just who succeeded your and you can turned Primary Minister), and therefore she has been attempting to tell you Blair’s poor side. Whether your courses had been devote connect having book time off Philosopher’s Brick, upcoming that it knowledge manage take place in 2002 (after Blair turned into Primary Minister).

But not, it absolutely was later reported that twenty two November are a tuesday, which it was in 1994

An identical problem concerns Nicolas Flamel, who was stated as being 665 at the time of the latest first guide, but Nicolas Flamel is actually a bona fide historical contour and wouldn’t have reached one to ages up until 1996, within time the first book is penned. The newest rebuttal because of it is the fact that day this new “real” Nicolas Flamel was created cannot correspond with the new Nicolas Flamel from Harry Potter.

A different condition is present away from Rubeus Hagrid’s period since Hogwarts’s gamekeeper. It’s meant in the show one to Hagrid received you to updates within this a few years of their expulsion away from college during the 1942. But in one to scene regarding Harry Potter therefore the Cup off Flames, Molly Weasley reminisces about Ogg, Hagrid’s preekeeper seem to overlap having Molly’s ages at school, it appears to be unlikely you to definitely she remembers a past gamekeeper. Yet not, you’ll be able to you to Hagrid didn’t be a good gamekeeper instantaneously once being expelled, but rather come once the Ogg’s secretary. This is possible just like the whenever Harry thinks he usually feel expelled to own flying on the broomstick versus consent in the first 12 months, the guy wonders when the he would be permitted to stick to due to the fact Hagrid’s assistant.